We'd love to hear from you, fill out the form below and one of the team will get back to you within in no time at all. Maybe you prefer a more direct route? Drop us an email at info@star-digital.co.uk or if you fancy a chat give us a call on: 01908 030 999.

The basics

Tell us a bit about it:

Handy things to tell us are what you’re aiming to achieve, what you have now, and your approximate budget and timescales for the project.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
September 18, 2023

How to Choose a Web Design Agency

How to Choose a Web Design Agency

In today's digital age, a strong online presence is crucial for businesses seeking success and growth. Whether you are starting a new venture or revamping your existing website, finding the right web design company that aligns with your needs can prove to be a daunting task. With a myriad of web design freelancers and agencies vying for your attention, making the right choice becomes a challenge in itself. So, how do you distinguish between them and identify the one that will cater to your unique requirements? 

In this comprehensive guide, we aim to provide you with all the necessary information and tools to make an informed decision that sets the stage for your online triumph. With over two decades of industry experience, we'll provide you with essential tips for choosing the perfect web design agency, backed by our firsthand observations. So, let’s dive into the world of web development!

Before You Begin Your Research

Set Your Goal 

As for everything else in your life, you need to set your goal before taking any actions. How many times did you get out of the house with the only intention of buying bananas, and then got back home with a bag full of everything you could possibly think of, EXCEPT bananas?


That’s why before beginning your research, you need to have your goal clear in mind: why are you thinking of collaborating with a web design agency? What do you wish to achieve from this partnership? What are the issues that have driven you to the conclusion that a web design agency might have been the best choice for you and your business?

Once you have the answer to all these questions, write it down. You want to make sure that you’ll bring those bananas back home. 

It might also be the case that you are not too sure of what your website needs. Maybe you are not getting the traffic you want, but you also don’t understand what’s wrong with your website or marketing strategy. If that’s the case, we can help with that as well. Either get in touch to speak directly with one of our advisors or complete our free online quiz to understand what is not working with your current website.

Set Your Budget

Another key aspect to make clear before beginning your research is: how much are you able or are you willing to spend for your online presence? 

We’d recommend setting your budget AFTER setting your goals, so it will be easier to assess how much this business choice means to you, if you have a clear idea of what are the benefits it could bring to your company. 

Remember: web design is an investment, so ultimately, you should be expecting to regain everything you spent in the first stage of web design in the form of website traffic, leads, conversions, form submissions, purchases, increased visibility and brand awareness. It might be good to ask the website design company you end up choosing what ROI can you expect by investing in their services.

Long-term commitment or just a one time revamp?

Finally, it is important to understand for how long you think you’ll require the agency’s services. 

If you work for a large or medium sized company with a marketing department, web design team or a dedicated marketing person able to take over from the web design company once their work is done, then a one time revamp might be the best choice for you. The marketing department will be able to observe and learn from what the agency does, and hopefully keep on going once the relationship comes to an end.

If on the other hand you work for a small company where there is no dedicated person or department that could take over from the web design agency, then you might want to consider working with the agency until you can hire someone solely responsible for marketing and website updates. 

If you decide to turn to a freelancer for your website needs, they might not be able to offer this type of service. On the contrary, agencies always have a dedicated marketing person or department that can continue curating your marketing strategy even after the initial website redesign has been completed. Knowing which of the two options you are looking for before you begin your research will help you identify the right web design agency for you much earlier in the decision making process.

Tips for choosing 

Once you have got your goal and budget ready, it’s time to begin your research. Here are top 5 recommendations to keep in mind when searching for the perfect web design agency:

Look at the company’s portfolio

Before you make any commitments, it's essential to take a close look at the web design agency's portfolio. The portfolio showcases the agency's previous work and gives you an insight into their style, creativity, and the types of projects they have handled. By examining their portfolio, you can assess whether their design aesthetics align with your vision and whether they have experience in creating websites similar to what you have in mind.

Pay attention to the variety of projects they have undertaken, as it reflects their versatility and ability to cater to different industries and business types. Additionally, look for case studies or success stories that demonstrate how their web design solutions have positively impacted their clients' businesses.

A robust portfolio not only showcases the agency's capabilities but also offers valuable proof of their expertise and commitment to delivering high-quality results. As you review their past work, consider whether their design approach aligns with your brand identity and if their websites are user-friendly and intuitive, emphasising a positive user experience.

Remember, a web design agency's portfolio is a glimpse into what they can accomplish for you. So, take the time to study it carefully, and use it as a vital tool to determine if they are the right fit for your project.

Look at company’s reviews

Another key aspect to take into account when choosing the right web design agency is looking at reviews and testimonials from their previous clients. Reviews provide valuable insights into the agency's reputation, customer satisfaction, and overall reliability. By reading the experiences of past clients, you can gain a deeper understanding of how the agency operates, communicates, and handles projects.

Pay attention to patterns in the reviews. If you notice consistent positive feedback regarding the agency's responsiveness, professionalism, and adherence to deadlines, it indicates a level of reliability that you can count on. Conversely, numerous negative reviews should be treated as warning signs, prompting further investigation or leading you to consider other options.

Remember that choosing a web design agency is an investment in your business's success. Reviews serve as a reliable gauge of the agency's track record and the overall quality of their services. By heeding the experiences of others, you can make a more informed choice, ensuring that you partner with a reputable agency that prioritises client satisfaction and delivers exceptional results.

Try to look for web design agencies who specialise in your field

Another crucial step in the decision-making process is to try to look for a web design agency who specialises in your field. Especially for businesses operating in niche industries or specific sectors, finding a web design agency that specialises in your field can be a game-changer. Such agencies possess an in-depth understanding of the unique challenges, trends, and customer preferences within your industry, allowing them to craft tailored solutions that resonate with your target audience.

A web design agency with industry-specific expertise will be well-versed in the language, design elements, and functionalities that are relevant to your business. This means they can create a website that not only looks visually appealing but also effectively communicates your brand message and value proposition to your specific market.

Moreover, specialised agencies are likely to be aware of the latest industry trends and best practices, enabling them to implement cutting-edge features and technologies that can set your website apart from competitors. They can also offer valuable insights on optimising user experience for your industry, resulting in higher engagement and conversions.

Also, web design agencies with experience in your field may already have established relationships with industry-specific tools, platforms, or integrations that can enhance your website's functionality. This can save you time and resources while ensuring a seamless and efficient development process.

Collaborating with a web design agency that specialises in your field not only streamlines the development process but also ensures that your website is uniquely tailored to meet the demands and expectations of your niche market. It's a strategic choice that can elevate your online presence, reinforce your brand authority, and drive sustainable growth within your industry.

Make sure that the agency is experienced with your current CMS (Content Management System)

When selecting a web design agency, it is essential to consider whether they have experience working with your current Content Management System (CMS). The CMS serves as the backbone of your website, enabling you to manage and update content easily. Ensuring that the agency is well-versed in the CMS you are using or plan to use is crucial for a seamless transition and efficient website management.

If you already have an existing website with a CMS in place, the agency's familiarity with your current platform can save time and resources during the redesign process. They will be better equipped to navigate the CMS, integrate new features, and preserve existing functionalities while implementing design improvements.

On the other hand, if you are looking to adopt a new CMS for your website, partnering with an agency experienced in that particular system can lead to a smoother and more successful migration. They will have the technical know-how and expertise to set up the CMS, optimise its performance, and train your team in its usage.

Moreover, a web design agency that specialises in your chosen CMS can offer valuable insights into best practices, plugins, and customisations specific to that platform. This expertise ensures that your website is fully optimised for performance, security, and user experience.

During the selection process, don't hesitate to ask potential agencies about their experience with your CMS. Inquire about past projects they have completed using the same platform, and request examples of websites they have designed within that CMS. This will provide you with a clear picture of their proficiency and their ability to handle your website requirements effectively.

Opt for a local web design company

Choosing a local web design company can offer a range of benefits that contribute to the success of your website project. Similarly to how it is best to opt for a web design agency who is experienced in your industry, working with a local company means that they will likely have a better grasp of the local market dynamics and audience preferences. They can tailor your website to resonate with your target audience within your specific region, ensuring that your online presence aligns with the local culture and trends.

Additionally, hiring a local web design company can lead to faster response times and efficient project management. In case of any urgent updates or technical issues, they can promptly address your needs and provide on-site support if required.


In conclusion, choosing the right web design agency is a critical decision that can significantly impact your online success. By following the steps outlined in this comprehensive guide, you can approach the selection process with confidence and make an informed decision. 

  • Setting clear goals and establishing a budget will help you align your vision with the agency's capabilities. 
  • Considering the agency's specialisation in your industry or CMS ensures a tailored and efficient development process. 
  • Reviews and testimonials from previous clients offer valuable insights into their reputation and client satisfaction. 
  • Opting for a local web design company fosters direct communication and understanding of your local market.

 With careful consideration and thorough research, you can find the perfect web design agency that will transform your online presence and propel your business towards growth and prosperity. Now, let’s put your newfound skills into practice! If you have your goals and budget lined up already, have a look at our portfolio (which includes all the relevant CMS we are experienced in) and get in touch if you think we might be a good fit for each other! 


What does a digital marketing agency do?

A digital marketing agency specialises in creating and implementing online marketing strategies to help businesses achieve their goals. They use various digital channels and tools, such as social media, search engine optimisation (SEO), pay-per-click (PPC) advertising, content marketing, email marketing, and more, to increase brand visibility, attract potential customers, and drive conversions. Essentially, a digital marketing agency helps businesses establish a strong online presence and reach their target audience effectively.

What can I expect from working with Star Digital?

Star Digital specialises in delivering comprehensive digital solutions tailored to your unique needs. Our expertise encompasses a wide range of services that are designed to elevate your online presence and drive results. With a dedicated team of skilled professionals, we work closely with you to understand your goals and craft innovative strategies to achieve them. From cutting-edge web development and captivating design to strategic digital marketing, our solutions are aimed at making your brand shine in the digital landscape.

What services does Star Digital offer?

We understand that every client and project is unique, which is why we provide a diverse selection of customised options to cater to your specific needs.We specialise in custom website design, digital marketing and web development. Please get in touch to discover all the services we can offer!

Written by
Astronaut - Moon - Star DigitalAstronaut - Moon - Star Digital